Posted by S. on December 30, 1998 at 22:28:00:
In Reply to: Re: Please stop "trying"-- posted by rob on December 28, 1998 at 19:28:10:
Hi rob,
No extended defense of Wu is asked for. You've been on the boards for
a long time. Simply state the reasons for the leaning.
The old photos are not a good guide, YCF had too many taken.
I realize the YZD is going aroung saying that the perpendicular people
have misunderstood his father, that leaning is Ok. YZD leans as part of his
extended, large frame form.
He is not a good representative of Yang style. Sorry!
Anyone who has done Tai Chi for a long time paying attention to the perpendiular
and experiencing all the power of that posture will understand how all that
is totally crippled by leaning.
Especially when it comes to applications, leaving aside Push Hands and its
relevance to applications.
YCF's combat form is a High frame, small circle form. No leaning in High Frame
postures, obviously.
This issue has come up a number of times over the years and I have not
read a reasonable defense of the change from perpedicular spine to 'straight
spine from heel to head leaning forward.
The 'imperial robe' story for Wu style saves a lot of face.
But it is very naive about Chinese family politics and family loyalty.
Anyway, give us your nutshell account for departing from the "Classics"
as well as departing from all of YCF's 'song' instructions about posture.
S.